A slow crank or rapid clicking with dim lights usually means a weak or flat battery. A car that starts after a jump but dies again soon after, or shows a battery warning light while driving, points to the charging system and alternator. A single loud click while the lights and radio work normally often means the starter. A car that cranks at normal speed but won't fire is usually not a battery problem at all. The only way to be sure is to test the battery and charging system, which takes a technician a few minutes.
Two caveats. Many modern cars have smart alternators that vary the charging voltage on purpose, so one reading isn't conclusive. And voltage only shows how charged the battery is, not how healthy it is. A worn-out battery can show a full 12.7 volts and still fail to start the car.
We also check the charging system with the engine running and look at the terminals and cables. Our battery and charging test is free, and done wherever your car is parked.
One more reason to test before replacing: a faulty alternator will kill a new battery too, and battery warranties do not cover damage caused by another fault in the car.